Where is online advertising going?
by: Peter Prestipino
Discusses t he brief history of online advertising through specific
ad strageis and discusses where online advertising is headed.
Is there such a thing as “traditional” online advertising? If there
is, it started with banners, moved to FFAs, took a step backwards with
SPAM, a hard right with classified advertising and then shot forward with
pay per click search engine. So how do you know where to spend your advertising
budget in the current market? If you’ve been responsible for your company’s
web advertising efforts over the years you might agree that the traditional
means of advertising worked; as least for a little while. So as new types
of advertising penetrate the market with increasing frequency, what do
you do with those proven stand-by methods of generating links and traffic?
Throw them out? Keep them around for posterity? Maybe give them a facelift?
Let’s review those traditional ad models then look at some experimental
models. TRADITIONAL ONLINE ADVERTISING MODELS
Banners:
Banner ads in the form of animated gifs are the most common and widely
used form of online advertising today. Banner ads reach the widest possible
audience because practically 100% of Internet users can view them without
any special plugins. Web marketers, advertisers and promoters have quickly
realized that banners under 12k in file size puts the ad in front of the
visitor as quickly as possible, increasing the chance of click-through
even though surfers are growing increasingly immune. New styles and shapes
of banners (such as skyscraper ads) have grown in popularity recently,
which is addressed in the “Experimental Advertising” section below. SPAM
What does SPAM stand for? It’s not “Stupid Pointless Annoying Message”
(which in some cases it could be) but rather “Sending and Posting Advertising
Messages.” It’s hard to believe SPAM is effective, but unarguably, it is.
While click-through rates continue to fall and legislation begins to rise,
it is a savvy advertiser’s best bet to stay away from it, unless of course
you’re selling Pasta Pots or Viagra. Rich mail – “Fancy SPAM”
Most likely, the e-mail messages you receive on a daily basis are text
only. Rich mail, on the other hand, allows graphics, video and audio to
be included in the e-mail message. When you open up a rich e-mail your
e-mail client automatically calls up your Internet connection and launches
an html page in your browser. E-mail clients that are offline will invite
you to click on the link when you have your Internet connection open again.
If your e-mail client does not support graphics you will receive the e-mail
in text only. While SPAM is still SPAM, rich mail has proven to be much
more effective than standard text messages. Pop-Ups/Pop-Unders:
This creative, yet completely obtrusive and annoying means of advertising
was once celebrated in some circles as the most innovative ad concept since
banners. It only took a short time before many users, sick of being trapped
in a never-ending onslaught of such ads, voiced their rejection. One can
only wonder when advertisers will recognize the public dissatisfaction
and move on to another more effective means to promote their companies.
Institutional Advertising:
While institutional or “in-house” advertising has been available since
the inception of the Internet, few companies have made an effort to utilize
the many different aspects of online advertising in one format as has 7Search.com
with its Direct Pay-Per-Text advertising. 7Search, a leader in the pay
per click search engine arena, has recently introduced this program which
enables its advertisers to advertise outside of its search return lists
using the same titles and descriptions seen on its search engine. The pay-per-click
model enables interested advertisers to leave behind the CPM impression
model and focus on the click conversions. Direct Pay-Per-Text is a patent-pending
concept from 7Search which will be released to the general public in the
coming months. Pay-Per-Click Search Engines
It’s hard to think of PPC search engines as a “traditional” means to
advertise online, but the ratio of those advertisers who do versus those
who don’t is staggering; in fact the majority have at least tried their
hand at leasing traffic. In a PPC agreement, the advertiser only pays for
qualifying clicks to the destination site based on a prearranged per-click
rate. The response on ads with well-written titles and descriptions targeted
to the users query pull response rates unseen in the ad industry previously.
The greatest advantage arguably is the ability to measure precisely the
rate of return versus your investment. Some of the most popular PPC search
engines are FindWhat.com, 7Search.com, Ah-ha.com and the industry leader
Overture. EXPERIMENTAL ONLINE ADVERTISING MODELS Traffic
Exchange Advertising:
Hit exchanges, actually a form of banner exchange, are a recent phenomenon
on the Internet. You will visit the site of a member of an exchange, and
in exchange, another member of the exchange will visit your site. The recent
explosion of hit exchanges on the web has diluted the effectiveness of
such a method of advertising. There have also been many instances of cheating,
in which a script is used to generate visits to a site. However, if you
have a product that is of interest to webmasters, and is low cost or has
a free version, there is no harm in giving hit exchanges a try.
Shockwave ads:
Shockwave is best suited for campaigns that want to utilize out-of-banner
real estate, such as applets, trading cards, and games. Director and Flash
provide the ability to embed interaction, video, and audio within the file,
making Shockwave files some of the richest ad units on the Web. Viral marketing
and strong brand interaction are two of the key strengths of Shockwave
ads. As these ads are typically “bandwidth monsters” the adoption has been
slow and will most likely remain that way. Other downsides include development
costs and the fact that it just won’t work without the Shockwave plug-in,
which (though downloaded by millions of users) is far from being a mainstay.
Interstitial ads.
Interstitials are ads that play between pages on a website, much like
television ads play between sections of a program. There are several variations
on the interstitial model: some play in the main browser window, while
some play in new, smaller windows; some are pre-cached, while some stream
ad content as it plays; some provide the ability to create very rich ads,
while some focus on smaller, faster-loading ads. Whatever the format, nearly
all interstitial ads perform very well if measured by both click-through
rates and brand recall.
Floating ads and DHTML
Types of floating ads include DHTML sponsorships, in which advertising
objects "fly" across the page on a preset course; cursor sponsorships,
in which the cursor turns into an advertising image; and scrolling ads,
in which an advertisement moves up and down the edge of a page as the user
scrolls up and down. Floating ads give the advertiser and publisher the
flexibility to achieve nearly any effect. However, as this is one of the
more daring types of online advertising, advertising and content must be
balanced on any given page. Floating ads (especially DHTML and cursors)
are best run for short periods to create brand awareness—running them for
longer periods can bring negative user feedback. It is important to understand
that online advertising is only effective if it generates significant response
and this applies to both traditional and experimental ads. Unfortunately,
the only way to discover the efficiency of your campaign is to test in
every format at least once with as many ads as you are able.
About the Author
Pete Prestipino is the founder and CEO of SCG - Swirling Circle Group,
a consortium of online marketers, promoters, SEO's, web designers, and
Internet consultants. For more information visit: www.SwirlingCircle.com |